Tuesday 23rd December 2014,
Comic Booked

Throne of Atlantis Event: Aquaman 16

Jeff Hill 02/01/2013 Reviews

Geoff Johns, Paul Pelletier

Throne of Atlantis Crossover

Spoiler alert! You have been warned!

Here’s the fight we’ve all been waiting to see for years. But if you’re anything like me, you didn’t actually know that until you saw it. Film critic Roger Ebert once famously reviewed Batman Begins, saying, “This is the movie I did not realize I was waiting for.” And I think that same mentality is true for me with the New 52’s reimagined version of Aquaman. Especially with the fight sequence expertly penned by Geoff Johns and Paul Pelletier that takes place in this issue. My only complaint is a brief one and probably an invalid one in some fellow readers’ own opinions. That being said, I simply wanted a whole issue of this fight, not just a glimpse here and there and a brief scene interrupted by the necessary but annoying character development scenes and plot device hint drop “look at me!” scenes.

Aquaman 16 Picture 2I get that Cyborg is a main character in the DC Universe, but no matter how much they try, even great writers like Geoff Johns simply cannot make a character that is almost complete garbage into someone I know and care about on a monthly, or in this crossover’s case, bi-weekly case. I get that his “sacrifice” is a big deal and all and I get that they need to incorporate him into the story as much as possible because, well, let’s face it, DC keeps cancelling all of their multicultural characters’ books, but come on. I think that he’s sort of stealing the thunder in Aquaman’s own book, which is a little easy to do when you have an awesome battle between the Justice League reserve members and the Atlantean army. But I’m okay with the sweet fight scene. In fact, I want more of that. But for a comic where the title character is only actually on eight pages (and isn’t even the focal point of said eight pages), I would at least want action or dialogue that affects him. I’m not saying that Cyborg needs to get killed off or even go away, but if the higher-ups at DC want him to take center stage, fine. Just give him his own book to do so in and give me the option of not being tricked into caring about him.

But while we’re being irritated by Cyborg’s unnecessary spotlight-stealing scenes, we get our last final surprise of the issue. With the final sequence revealing that Orm is not controlling the Atlantean army of fish people and fish monsters, but it is in fact Vulco, the mysterious and thought-to-be heroic stranger we met just recently in the New 52, we get a sense that things are escalating quickly as we approach the ending. His motive seems pretty basic, but sometimes the classics are such because they work. As he tells Dr. Shin that he was exiled from Atlantis and is going to have revenge on both the surface world and the depths of the ocean by causing an all-out war between the two. Now, this isn’t exactly a new concept in comics, or any fiction for that matter, but it is so well executed by Johns that we don’t even seem to mind. So I’m convinced that this is going to be a great finale and there will be some definite ramifications for both the team as a whole and all of the supporting cast members of Aquaman’s own title. And with that last page revelation, you can rest assured that this lifelong fan will be back for the sure to be epic conclusion in Justice League in a couple of weeks.

Like this Article? Share it!

About The Author

Jeff Hill is a moderately reformed frat boy turned writer/teacher living the dream in Lincoln, Nebraska. He does freelance work and writes fiction, none of which is about corn or the husking of corn. His work has appeared in over a dozen publications and his mom has a binder full of printed copies for any doubters. Plus, he's the Chief Creative Officer of Comic Booked. So that's pretty neat, too.

  1. kcassidy 02/01/2013 at 2:02 pm

    I didn't mind the Cyborg-focused issue, only because it did progress the story along. Vic is not my favorite character, and I appreciate him being in the JL, but I miss his interactions with Nightwing, Changeling, etc. in the classic New Teen Titans era.

    • jeffhillwriter 02/01/2013 at 10:06 pm

      I never really cared for him much as a character, but I do sort of miss the whole Titans "family" aspect. The League was a team. The Society seemed almost like an army at times. But the Titans just had a whole other aspect/dynamic going for them… I guess I can appreciate what DC and Johns are trying to do with the character, but it seems a little out of left field. Maybe it warrants a re-read after the storyline's conclusion.

  2. Scorp_Moonopoly 02/02/2013 at 4:43 pm

    Oh, this was Aquaman? I thought I recognized that cover! Seriously though, I mean it is a crossover but my brain just treated it like another issue of Justice League.

    • jeffhillwriter 02/03/2013 at 11:42 pm

      Yeah. Which is okay, this one time, I suppose. I just need less Cyborg and more Arthur. Or at least more things that directly affect him.

Leave A Response