Friday 19th December 2014,
Comic Booked

The New 52 Review: Batman #1

James Victor Von Halstead 09/22/2011 Reviews

DC‘s New 52 relaunch is almost finished, with several hits and a few misses. The titles I was most excited for were Detective Comics and Batman, and if you’ve read my review, you know I was very satisfied with Detective Comics. Now it’s time to turn my attention to Batman #1. Writer Scott Snyder is a relative newcomer to comics, having only been writing since 2009. His last run was on Detective Comics, nearly finishing the run, so my expectations going in were high. Greg Capullo is in charge of artwork, including the cover, with Jonathan Glapian and Fco Plascenia handling the inking and colors.

Batman #1 coverWe start with Batman narrating about the Gotham Gazette and how they run an article entitled “Gotham Is”, a piece that lets Gotham’s own citizens reflect on their city . While reflecting, he also happens to be fighting off a massive breakout from Arkham Asylum. All the regulars line up, Two-Face, Scarecrow, Black Mask, Killer Croc, Riddler, as well as some new faces. Batman is not without his own allies, although this team up is one no one thought they would see. After debriefing Commissioner Gordon on the events and assuring him that a certain rumor is untrue, he races off to attend a party he is throwing as Bruce Wayne. In attendance are three generations of Robins, Dick Grayson, Tim Drake and Damian Wayne. Bruce unveils his new plan for Gotham: a complete rebuilding of the city’s  infrastructure. We also meet mayoral candidate Lincoln March. Bruce and Lincoln share some pleasantries, but duty calls and Batman rushes off to the scene of a brutal murder with a warning to a high powered socialite of Gotham.

Much like with Green Lantern, Batman seems to be relatively untouched by the the relaunch. This issue begins with much of the history intact, and simply opens a new chapter. One problem I had was that the issue felt a little rushed. Though the opening was amazing, it was over before I knew what hit me. It seemed perhaps a bit too easy for Batman to defeat so many foes. The speech given by Wayne also seemed tacked on, as if they were trying to channel some of the anxiety people feel regarding the state of various cities and even the country itself. The writing was good, but nothing stellar and the dialogue was decent at best. The ending sets up the next issue nicely though, and hopefully the story will deliver a little more.

Panel Batman #1-New 52Another complaint I had was regarding the artwork. After the amazing art in Detective Comics #1, this seemed like a step in the wrong direction. No panel stood out above the rest, and the characters looked a little bland. The only way I can really describe it is “indie”, which didn’t seem to fit with the tone of the book. Others may like the style but it wasn’t to my taste.

Overall I’d say it was a bit underwhelming, with nothing that really stands out. It’s not as graphic as it’s counterpart, though there are still some disturbing images in the book and it is darker than most superhero books. If you are a die hard Batman fan, it’s worth the purchase, otherwise you could probably skip it.

Like this Article? Share it!

About The Author

When not battling the forces of the undead you can find James at the local cinema watching whatever comic book inspired film that was just released, for the third time.

  1. Robb Orr 09/22/2011 at 1:39 pm

    I tend to agree with this review. I thought Bruce Wayne came off as a big real estate player ready to gentrify Gotham. On the art – Capullo is one of my very favorite artists. He tends to start off mellow, like in Haunt, then come on with a vengence. I did enjoy some of the new Bat-tech. I think I will have to check out a few more issues to come to a final verdict on this title.

    • James Victor Von Hal 09/22/2011 at 8:59 pm

      My biggest complaint would be how easily he dealt with the breakout in Arkham. I mean I've read stories where Killer Croc has nearly killed him single handed. the artwork, not terrible, but not what I was expecting. I am interested in the next issue, hopefully the writing picks up better.

  2. Lee K 09/28/2011 at 12:28 pm

    I'm not a regular bat book reader, but I have read and collected DC for…well since the books were twenty cents and I have to say I enjoyed the Batman relaunch more than any of the other solo books, both art & story, with the exception of batgirl although I haven't read today's books yet and I have been waiting for aquaman and all-star western since day 1 – I recommend this book to the casual bat reader over the diehard fan.

    • James Victor Von Hal 09/29/2011 at 9:22 pm

      See I would agree that Detective Comics was a good starting point for new readers, but Batman just continued where the previous storyline left off. Characters are brought in, like Tim, Dick, and Damian, but you don't know who they are, so it leaves some questions up in the air. Also it felt to me, more like a filler episode than one that should start a new run of the series.

      I'm also waiting to pick up Aquaman, and I might get Flash as well.

Leave A Response