Friday 19th December 2014,
Comic Booked

Comic Polity: Citizenship

Comic Booked Retail 05/04/2011 Features, Reviews
Perhaps many of you have heard that America’s beloved Superman plans to renounce his U.S. citizenship to the UN in an upcoming storyline.  The reason given within David Goyer’s story, “The Incident,” in Action Comics #900 is to separate Superman’s actions from perceived U.S. policy.

This concept should be extremely interesting to all of us.  Not only is today’s world caught in the crossfire of rapid globalism vs. vicious tribalism, but we are also in the midst of great personal turmoil over the ever-changing definitions of international right and wrong.  Does might make right?  Should nations stay neutral in the face of human suffering?  These questions make many peoples of many different nationalities inquire about governmental alignment.

I submit that this issue has at least two primary facets:  A)  the issue of loyalty to a nation-state and B)  the the transcendence of objective morality.

Truth, Justice, and the American Way

Up until this point Superman has functioned as an agent of the American ideals, warding off the odd-screwball maniac as well as the more powerful intergalactic super villain.  However, in order to keep the character interesting (and hopefully not painting him into a corner) Superman scribes have decided that humanity as a whole needs a savior to combat the idea and travesty of general human suffering.  As Superman states within the book, “Truth, justice, and the American…it’s not enough anymore.”Superman, as an agent of good, has looked around at the human condition and decided to say “no” to it.  No to human injustice, no to famine, no to disease, and no to natural disaster.  On one hand, this brings the character to a whole new level of existence–but to many, this change robs the persona of a defining characteristic.  Traditionally, Superman has fought for the U.S. best interest.  But is that enough?Some may call me a liberal, or an elitist (http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/04/29/hijacked-superman-turned-loving-anti-american/), but I say that if a person is knowledgeable about what is right and is capable of doing what is right, and still does not, then it is wrong.  We have come to the point in United States history that we may be acting against the moral right.  Would it be so bad if we had a role model that did what is right regardless of national allegiance?

Even as I type this, my insides are churned about because I want America to do what is right all the time.  But we do not.  It is inevitable.  I remember bumper stickers that stated, “My Country, Right or Wrong.”  And as patriotic as the message is, we are not called to stand by as moral and ethical wrongs are perpetrated.

Superman’s choice can be no easy decision.  And it is no easy decision for the rest of us.  What the writer has done is put forth an example of one individual with power that stood up and said, “There is more to this world than the nation-states we cling to.”  This can be classified as the cry of a Humanist, but it can also be classified as someone who has opened his or her eyes and understood that the final authority is not held by those people that can make mistakes, or who have compromised their way to the top.

Is the U.N. the final authority?  Absolutely not.  Is your country?  No, though participation in the social contract dictates certain conditions.  So what is the final authority?  Superman did not say.  Superman didn’t bow to democratic ideals, though he desires them for all individuals; he didn’t defect to another, equally convoluted polity; he didn’t swear allegiance to a self-proclaiming authority.  What he did was tell America that the individual–the needy, the orphan, the hungry, the sick, the fellow human–needs help.  And that he will do his best to offer that help.

Far too long has he been a symbol of political viewpoints.  Far too long has he been restricted in his definition of good.  Far too long has he been living in the inferior circle of accountability.

Still…a question comes with this season of change:  what happens if the moral right finds itself opposed to Superman’s former dependent?  How will America react?  How will Superman react and what will that say about where America has come to rest?

Like this Article? Share it!

About The Author

What’s that??? Need a local Virginia Beach Comic Book Shop? Look no further….Stop by and visit Comic Booked.com, conveniently located off I-264, near Lynnhaven Mall. Comic books. Pull Service. Old toys that rule… Premier WOTC Store -Your Virginia Beach source for Magic: The Gathering. MTG singles, decks, supplies, boxes, events, and so much more. FNM. Magic Tournaments. PreRelease Events. Game Day. FREE Wi-Fi +Comic Booked

  1. Nick Furious 05/04/2011 at 8:00 am

    Hah! Kirby when I heard this I knew you'd be all over it! I'm not sure how I feel about this yet, but I trust the story will be remarkable as DC has been putting out some decent material lately.

  2. Andy Kirby 05/04/2011 at 9:00 am

    LOL that's great…my reputation for not being able to keep quiet proceeds me!

  3. Robb Orr 05/04/2011 at 12:53 pm

    Excellent piece, Andy. The best I have read on this topic yet! This type of Superman story arc is always fun. I enjoyed "Red Menace" and have been liking the similar discussions this new twist is creating. Thought provoking writing (as always).

    • Andy Kirby 05/05/2011 at 3:37 am

      Again, thanks for the kind words. I tend to agree that this turn of events, whether is sticks or not, will open up a lot more impactful stories for the Man of Steel.

  4. Skott of Fables 05/04/2011 at 4:25 pm

    Better you doing this than me. I was going to do a write up on this but I have a very difficult time using family friendly words in situations like this.

    The fact that morons like Cal Thomas and those idiots from the Huffington Compost have decided to weight in on the supposed political impact of this both amuses me, because the writers of the Huffington Compost are brain dead at best, and angers me, because of the comments and insults thrown at us comics fans by that fool Thomas.

    This is a fake controversy. There is nothing major here. All anyone needs to do is actually read the story instead of focusing on ONE PANEL and they will understand what Superman is actually doing.

    I'm sure this will come up on the Podcast this week and if it does I'll try to keep my comments short because otherwise names will be named and challenges will be made. Challenges the likes of which Cal Thomas cannot win.

    Because I'm the Skott…and I'm…Awesome!

    • Andy Kirby 05/05/2011 at 3:38 am

      Skott, I can't wait to hear your rant on the podcast. Go ahead and throw down the gauntlet!!!! Do it!! Because you are SKOTT and you are AWESOME!!

      • Skott of Fables 05/05/2011 at 10:53 pm

        Something tells me that you and I could have a very good time with rants.

        I like you because you encourage it. Not many people are willing to do that.

        • Andy Kirby 05/06/2011 at 6:00 pm

          Bro, you mean to tell me that we think the exact same way on this thing? what a let down! LOL

Leave A Response